THE CHRONICLES OF
HER GRACE THE DUCHESS
Jackie Wilson (1934-1984) – Reet Petite – Recorded in 1957
Written by Berry Gordy III (1929), Billy Davis (1932-2004), & Gwen Gordy Fuqua (1927-1999)
-oOo-
8: IF DUCHESS WERE A DUCHESS
A FAIRY TALE FOR
THE YOUNG AT HEART
PART 6
-oOo-
To aid the reader of this tale, what follows is the cast of principal characters:
-oOo-
Hello, Goodbye (1967) – The Beatles
The next day Prince Anatole was at the Alexander II Park very early. He walked around the park wishing the time would pass quickly so that the Chaperone would soon arrive. He hadn’t sleep a wink since his mind was clouded with thoughts of Princess Eugénie – the beautiful Princess Eugénie! He felt his heart skip a beat each time he said her name!
He had visited the park a number of times, but had noticed nothing about it. Today it seemed he was noticing so many things. How beautiful the park was, how green the grass was etc. He saw the sunrise today, something he had seen a thousand times before, but today, it seemed more spectacular with more vivid colours. At first, he could not understand why he felt this way, but after a while, he realised that nothing was ever going to be the same now – not since he had met the Princess Eugénie!
The Erstwhile Alexander II Park, Odessa, now known as
The Taras Shevchenko Park of Culture and Recreation
-oOo-
At last the Prince came to where he hoped the Chaperone would be. She was there and was seated on a wooden form placed for the weary traveler. After the usual greetings the Chaperone quickly came to the point. She told Anatole that she had brought Prince Eugénie, along with her sisters, to the Park and that she would allow him time to save goodbye to her. She would not listen to any entreaties of the Prince for she knew the dangers that lurked. She reminded him again of the vicious nature of the Grand Duke and how those that dared to cross him met grizzly endings. She added that if the Grand Duke learned that the Princess had dared to have affection for another, her life would be made totally miserable.
Within minutes, Eugénie arrived with her sisters. The Chaperone said that she would leave the couple alone for one hour while she showed the park to Eugénie’s sisters. And with that, she literally scooped up her charges leaving Eugénie and Anatole alone.
Anatole tried hard to explain to the Princess that although his feelings for her were deep, they could not, and dare not, see each other again. He gave her a multitude of excuses, none of which Eugénie believed. She made no effort to speak and contradict anything that Anatole said. She just starred at him . Her eyes were moist and the occasional teardrop rolled down her cheek.
The Meeting Place, St. Pancras Station, London
The Manhattans – (Let’s just) Kiss and Say Goodbye
Written by Winfred ‘Blue’ Lovett (1936-2014) & Recorded in 1976
Anatole could stand it no more. If only she would scream at him or slap his face, their goodbye would be easier. But she just sat there like a beautiful statue, starring at him with those loving eyes and his heart melted and his resolve left him. He took her in his arms and they kissed, and this was not the kiss of a goodbye.
-oOo-
Despite the words of the Chaperone, neither Eugénie nor Anatole could bear the thought of not seeing each other again. The Chaperone realised this after their meeting in the park and decided that she could do no more to keep them apart. However, she warned them once more of the vengeful nature of the Grand Duke and asked them to take the greatest care.
-oOo-
During the remainder of the visit of Her Grace’s family to the estate of the Grand Duke in Odessa, the young couple organised ways to meet. Eugénie would offer a multitude of excuses that required her to visit the Grand Magasins or the Musea or the Parks in Odessa and Prince Anatole would arrange to cross paths with her as often as possible. Eugénie would always be accompanied by Louisa and her younger sisters. Louisa would always help to allow the young couple to be alone for some time.
Young Lovers (1969) by Aldo Luongo (1941)
At each meeting, the Prince would feign astonishment by their surprising meeting, but of course those present knew that their meeting was not merely by chance.
Marni Nixon (1930-2016) – Hello Young Lovers
This song is from the Richard Rodgers (1902-1979) & Oscar Hammerstein II (1895-1960)
musical, The King & I produced on Broadway (1951) and in the West End (1953)
-oOo-
Meanwhile the Grand Duke Alexi Sergei Rostovitch was putting his plan in place which was to snare the lovely and youthful Princess Eugénie. What he did not know was that the Princess Eugénie had given her heart and love to Prince Anatole. She had confided her feelings to her mother who said that she needed to stop and think before she presented her wishes to her father.
-oOo-
A few days after the Ball, the Grand Duke invited Prince Karl to luncheon with him at his Club in Odessa. This was the most exclusive Club in the City and was an establishment that the Prince could never afford to join or visit unless invited. He was flattered by the invitation and was honoured to be introduced to some of the most powerful and influential figures of the City. The Prince, sadly, was out of his element in mixing with such people and could offer little conversation. However, this did not matter to the Grand Duke since the Prince had not been invited for chitter chatter!
After a sumptuous lunch and once the Cognac had been served and their cigars had been chosen, the Prince felt himself relaxed, but was suddenly brought back to the reality of the moment when the Grand Duke informed Prince Karl that he wanted to make Princess Eugénie his wife! At first the Prince was lost for words, but once he regained his senses, he said that his daughter was far too young to think about marriage at this time. The Grand Duke, as cunning as ever, said that he more than understood this, and that he was prepared to wait a little. And now he played what he thought was his trump card!
-oOo-
Marry Me (Any Tom, Dick or Harry) – written by Cole Porter (1891-1964) for the musical Kiss Me Kate
From the film version of Kiss Me Kate with Ann Miller (1923-2004), Tommy Rall (1929-2020),
Bobby Van (1928-1980) & Bob Fosse (1927-1987)
-oOo-
The Grand Duke said that he realised that such a marriage would mean his daughter moving to St. Petersburg and would need to accompany him on journeys out of Russia, and that such a separation would be most painful to the Prince and his wife. However, he was prepared to offer the Prince a home in St. Petersburg to be used whenever his family chose. He quickly added that this pied-à-terre (consisting of eight bedrooms!) would be fully staffed at the expense of the Grand Duke of course! and would prove beneficial in helping to find suitable matches for his other daughters. In addition, he said that he was prepared to make a certain sum of money available to the Prince to be used as he wished since he appreciated that the cost of raising eligible daughters was not always easy to meet. The Prince could hardly believe his ears and could say nothing. The Grand Duke naturally had known that the Prince would be speechless at this offer and said that he recommended that he discuss the proposal with his charming wife, the Princess Caroline.
After dropping these bombshells, the Grand Duke stood up from the table and asked to be excused since he had another appointment to rush to ……. something of importance to The Czar. At that, the Prince found himself sitting at the table alone, totally and utterly bewildered by what he had heard!
One thing that Prince Karl understood, the Grand Duke’s interest in Eugénie was certainly not that he had suddenly fallen in love with her or caring for her happiness, but rather as someone to give him a heir! And once she did, he would toss her aside and she would be left with a life of misery! No, he would not barter his daughter at any price regardless of what revenge the Grand Duke would reap on him!
-oOo-
Somehow the Prince stumbled back to the estate where he quickly told Princess Caroline about the Grand Duke’s proposal and his offer. Prince Karl said that there was much to think about now, but before he could finish, the Princess interrupted him by echoing his own thoughts in that their daughter was not for sale! She did, however, and contrary to her better judgement, agree to inform Princess Eugénie of the proposal. The young Princess was summoned and told by her mother of the request for her hand in marriage.
The Princess Eugénie was horrified at the suggestion that she should marry such a person as the Grand Duke! And then she dropped her own bombshell into the mix. She told her parents that she wished to marry Prince Anatole and that he was planning on visiting her father the following day!
Penelope with The Suitors painted by Bernardino Pinturicchio (1454-1513)
-oOo-
Prince Karl was as horrified by this suggestion as he had been by the one of the Grand Duke. But this second proposal reminded Princess Caroline of her earlier life, and she remained silent while her husband ranted about the reputation of Prince Anatole and that his daughter had entered into a liaison without the knowledge of her parents. By now Eugénie was in tears and clinging to her mother.
When the Prince appeared to have run out of steam, he collapsed into a chair and began to talk in a less grieved manner about the young Prince Anatole’s deplorable reputation. Princess Eugénie said that she was fully aware of his past since he had confessed all to her. Despite knowing this, she loved him and that she had forgiven him his past errors. At this Princess Caroline spoke and told her daughter to go to her room as she and her father had much to discuss.
When Prince Karl and Princess Caroline were alone, the Prince still seated in his chair, admitted to being mentally exhausted by the events of the day and could not think! His wife said that regardless, they needed to think and she suggested that nothing should be done until the young Prince presented himself tomorrow, and with this, she got up and left the room. She wanted to find her daughter and learn more about Prince Anatole.
-oOo-
The following afternoon Prince Anatole presented his card to the butler and requested an audience with Prince Karl and Princess Caroline. The Prince was smartly dressed in his uniform and cut a dashing figure. He introduced himself to Princess Eugénie’s parents, quickly bowing his head with each greeting and shaking Prince Karl hand along with a click of his heels, and kissing the extended hand of Princess Caroline.
The young Prince declined the offer of a cup of tea from Princess Caroline, but said that, with their permission, he would like to tell them why he had asked for this audience. After a minute of silence, Anatole stood up from his chair, coughed slightly and said that he had come to request the honour for the hand of Princess Eugénie in marriage. With that, Anatole appeared to lose control of his legs and collapsed back into his chair!
Mike Preston (1938) – Marry Me (1961)
Prince Karl eventually asked if he would tell Princess Caroline and himself, how his feelings for their daughter developed since his request appeared somewhat sudden to them.
Anatole welcomed Prince Karl’s invitation to tell them about his first meeting with Princess Eugénie, and how he has come to love and cherish her. When he discussed the young Princess, Princess Caroline noticed how his face lit up and his eyes sparkled. He talked of their initial meeting at The Grand Ball, of the dance that they shared and of their accidental meetings in shops and then of their less-accidental meetings in the park.
Anatole said that he had never met anyone like the Princess Eugénie. He continued by saying that he soon realised that she was most intelligent and extremely well educated together with a quick wit. He said that she had a unique charm. a glow, and an honesty that he had not found in the young women of St. Petersburg. Anatole stopped talking for a second or two and then added that he fell in love with their daughter and hoped that the Prince and Princess would not hold the horrors of his past life against him. He said that he knew that this was indeed much to request. Finally he said that they could be assured that he promised to love her, provide for her, and hopefully, never bring her any reason to doubt his love.
Anatole stood up and ended his discourse by saying that he realised that he was not perhaps the ideal suitor that they might have hoped for their daughter, but he assured them that she had caused him to reevaluate his life and now he realised that he had been wasting his life until the night of the Grand Ball. Finally he said that no one would love her and treasure her as he would. After this he thanked them for their kindness in allowing him to speak.
Love Changes Everything sung by Michael Ball (1962)
From the musical Aspects of Love (1989) written by
Andrew Lloyd Webber (1948), Don Black (1938) and Charles Hart (1961)
It was now Prince Karl’s turn to stand up whereupon he thanked the young Prince for his account and said that he and his wife would need to discuss the matter with their daughter and requested that he return the following afternoon for their decision in the matter. At this Prince Anatole thanked them both, and after hands were shaken and kissed again, he bade them adieu until the following afternoon and quickly took his leave without asking to see the young Princess.
-oOo-
Princess Eugénie’s grandmother, the Princess Katherine, had met her husband-to-be, the Prince Nikolai, at a Ball in Kyiv (Київ; Kiev) in Ukraine. Prince Nikolai came from a poor, but honest family who lived on a small estate on the edge of a Hamlet among the Ural Mountains that is now part of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Neither his family nor that of his wife came from wealth and as a result, they lacked sufficient funds for their children to be presented at Court or spend an extended time in St. Petersburg and take opportunity to find suitable husbands for their three daughters and a wife for their only son, Prince Karl. However everyone enjoyed living on their small estate, and although they lacked finery, none lacked love.
-oOo-
Her Grace’s parents, Prince Karl and Princess Caroline, met during a rare visit of Prince Karl to St. Petersburg. He first saw his future wife in a large store during a shopping expedition. Caroline was English and was employed by a wealthy family as Governess to their children. She was accompanying the family on the shopping trip in the hope that her presence would control her normally unruly charges. When Prince Karl and Caroline first saw each other, it was love at first sight, and after a whirlwind courtship, he presented the young and charming Caroline to his parents.
Prince Karl’s parents, Prince Nikolai and Princess Katherine, were horrified at first when his son presented the charming young lady since it was their hope that his son would make a better match (i.e., a richer one) to help restore their estate to its former glory since his father and grandfather had allowed it to decline.
But, as Her Grace would say whenever she was in a whimsical and somewhat romantic mood, love conquers all, and she would then add when telling this tale, that her grandparents lived happily ever after despite being as poor as church mice! But she added that her grandfather did eventually restore the estate. After a pause, Her Grace would wipe away a tear from her eye and then sigh deeply!
-oOo-
Her Grace’s grand parents, Prince Karl and Caroline, were married in the little church on the edge of the forest. They lived on the family’s estate and were overjoyed when each of their four daughters were born with Princess Eugénie being the eldest and followed by Louisa, Mary and Ann. Their daughters were accomplished having been educated by their mother who had once earned her living as a Governess and attempting to educate spoiled disinterested children.
-oOo-
Naturally Prince Karl was not overly impressed with Prince Anatole’s prospects, since he would remain a soldier and would, no doubt, find himself in situations where he would be tempted by the vices open to him. But he had to admit that the young Prince did sound sincere in his affection for his daughter.
The presence of Prince Anatole and his proposal once again reminded Princess Caroline of her own proposal made by Prince Karl. She was a mere Governess and Prince Karl was as eager and determined to marry her as Prince Anatole now appeared to marry their daughter. She said that despite their own romance being whirlwind, his parents had noticed the love that they shared. And now, they still loved each other and she knew that they would spend the rest of their lives together with joy. Princess Caroline said that she felt that she could not deny her own daughter the same opportunity. Her talk with her daughter had revealed to her that the Princess Eugénie felt the same towards Anatole as she had, and still did, to Prince Karl. She believed that although she was young and inexperienced in the ways of the world, she loved the young man with a deep and lasting love.
The Prince was taken aback at the words of his wife, but they set him thinking. He thought back to his first meeting with Caroline when she was a Governess and how his heart raced at the thought of her and how he knew she was the one that he wanted to marry and cherish.
The Prince and the Princess spent the remainder of the day and late into the night discussing this matter and had periodically asked their daughter to return several times to answer further questions. With each return, her parents realised more and more the deep passion that burned in their daughter heart. And now after all their talk, they needed to speak further with Prince Anatole when he returned the following day.
-oOo-
After Princess Eugénie left her parents alone, Prince Karl and Princess Caroline sat quietly and thought about the decision they had to make. Once they started to talk, they discussed how it would be if they were to agree to this love-match and how it would be if they did not.
From the limited discussions that they had had with their daughter, they knew that her feelings for the young man were deep. Prince Karl said that he only hoped that Prince Anatole’s feelings were as deep. Princess Caroline said that she knew that were. The Prince smiled at his wife for he had learned long ago that she was an unusual woman with a keen sense for what was true and what was not, and was invariably right in her assessments. Anyway, they knew that their daughter would be heartbroken and would be inconsolable if they did not agree to the union.
The Princess Caroline remembered the pain she felt after her husband’s family said no to their wish to marry. Prince Karl said that he loved Caroline and that he would not give her up. And he did not. And now here they were facing the same situation with their own daughter. She and her husband went against his family and they have had no regrets.
Now if they agreed to the union of their daughter and Prince Anatole, they knew that there would be repercussions – very serious repercussions – since the Grand Duke was not a person to cross and that he would seek revenge on the whole family. They knew that in order for the young couple to have a life without fear, they would need to leave Russia and do so quickly for it was certain that the Grand Duke would pursue them and would most certainly have Anatole killed!
For the couple to venture anywhere in Europe and seek sanction would be tantamount to signing Anatole’s death warrant since the Grand Duke had spies and allies everywhere. But if they were to travel east, it would be a different matter. He had few allies east of The Urals and certainly did not enjoy universal admiration there. Prince Karl had a number of friends living across The Eurasian Steppe and felt certain that there would be many willing and able to help the young couple escape the clutches of the tyrant.
-oOo-
That night both Anatole and Eugénie felt that their hearts would burst with anticipation at the answer Eugénie’s parents promised to give the next day. Each played out various scenarios as what would take place the following day. When light was first appearing over the trees at the far end of the garden, both fell into sleep which was filled with more images of their loved one.
-oOo-
The next afternoon found Prince Karl, Princess Caroline and Prince Anatole seated in one of the drawing rooms of the House. Prince Karl questioned the young Prince further on his feelings for their daughter and asked how he would support her and their eventual family. The Prince said that he had some money that his grandparents had left to him and that he was now a Professional Soldier in The Service of The Czar. All very nice the Prince thought should they agree to the marriage and be able to remain in Russia. However the Grand Duke would most certainly seek revenge once he learned of their relationship! He said that should they agree to the union then he and Eugénie would have to leave Russia since he felt certain that the Grand Duke would pursue them and have him killed. Anatole said that he would live anywhere and do any work available, as long as he was with Princess Eugénie.
Finally, Prince Karl asked if he had discussed his marital plans with his parents. Anatole said that he had not since he knew that they would be angered, as they expected him to marry a wealthy member of Court. And so he thought it best not to mention it. He said that he was not especially close with his family – certainly nothing like the relationship enjoyed by Princess Eugénie with her family. He continued by saying that he hardly knew his parents, as his father had always been too busy to bother with his children, much preferring the company of members of the Court and of his Club. And his mother found his presence to be intrusive and bothersome and so allowed governesses and tutors to raise him, although she had expressed some dismay when he joined the army. He said that his parents would certainly be furious with him and probably disown him. But he was prepared for this outcome.
-oOo-
And now, the Princess Eugénie was sent for and the situation explained to her. She was overjoyed to learn her parents decision and said that although she was sad at having to leave her parents and sisters, it would not be forever. Her Parents and Anatole looked surprised at this remark. Eugénie smiled amid her tears and said that the Grand Duke could not possibly live forever and then they would be free to return! Her parents gave a sigh of relief since they had forgotten this!
-oOo-
Anatole smiled also, but not for the same reason for he now knew that his dream was going to come true ……. that Eugénie and he would spend the rest of their lives together.
You are Beautiful – Johnny Mathis
-oooOooo-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank Ms Linda Fineman for suggesting the use of the painting, Penelope and The Suitors, here
——oooOOOooo——
Click here to GO to:
THE CHRONICLES OF HER GRACE THE DUCHESS
9. IF DUCHESS WERE A DUCHESS – A FAIRY TALE
PART 7 – THE RUSSIAN STORY
THE YOUNG COUPLE FLEES
-oooOooo-
Click here to RETURN to:
THE CHRONICLES OF HER GRACE THE DUCHESS
7. IF DUCHESS WERE A DUCHESS – A FAIRY TALE
PART 5 – THE RUSSIAN STORY –
I COULD HAVE DANCED ALL NIGHT
—oooOooo—
—oooOooo—
Click here to GO to:
PAGE THIRTY-ONE: IN MEMORIAM
CASANOVA/PUPPY 14th JUNE, 2010 – 25th MAY, 2024
LIFE WITHOUT CASANOVA/PUPPY
—oooOooo—
I was eager for the next chapter in this love story, and it didn’t disappoint! I actually feel the most sorry for Prince Karl, since few things are as excruciating as indecision and uncertainty. All the other players are confident of their opinions, but he is the one torn by conflicting arguments. He also feels the heaviest burden of responsibility, as the male head of the family.
I had kind of lost sight of the Grand Duke’s advanced age and anticipated death, but as the proverb says, “Only the good die young!”
The musical selections were beautiful, and I loved the pictures of the park in Odessa, bursting with life and color. Seeing them, I never would have guessed it was Russia. I tend to picture Russia in gray melancholy tones, which I’m sure is an unfair stereotype.